The First 72 Hours After a Family Emergency: Who Has Your Kids?
I have this conversation with parents all the time. And this time of year, right between Mother's Day and Father's Day, most parents are already thinking about the people they love most: their kids. But there's one question I find many parents haven't fully answered, even when they think they have.
Most have talked about who would raise their children if something happened to them. Maybe it came up on a long drive, over dinner, or during one of those late-night conversations where you and your spouse nodded and agreed on the person you'd want.
But here's what I tell them: a conversation is not a plan.
If something happened to you tonight, that choice doesn't automatically carry legal weight. If the people you've chosen aren't named in the right documents, a court not you will decide who cares for your children. And that decision could be made by a judge who has never met your family and knows nothing about your values, relationships, or wishes.
Here's what every parent needs to know and what you can do now to make sure that decision stays in your hands.
When a Stranger Ends Up Making the Call
When I ask parents what they think would happen if something happened to them, most assume the right people would simply step in. A grandparent. A sibling. A godparent. A close friend. The people who love their children would figure it out.
But that's not how the law works.
If you haven't legally named guardians, a judge will decide who raises your children. And that judge has never met your family. They don't know your values, your relationships, or who your children would feel safest and most comfortable with. They don't know who you trust to make healthcare decisions, guide educational choices, or raise your children the way you would want them raised.
What they do see are the people asking to be appointed. One family member may believe they're the obvious choice. Another may feel just as strongly. And when there are no clear legal instructions, those disagreements can quickly become court battles.
I've seen loving families torn apart by these situations. Grandparents, aunts, uncles, siblings, and close friends, people who genuinely want what's best for the children can find themselves on opposite sides of a legal dispute at the worst possible time. And the outcome isn't always what the parents would have wanted.
Bottom line: if you haven't legally named guardians, the decision about who raises your children may be made by a judge, through a court process you never intended your family to face. The people you trust most may have no automatic legal right to step in, no matter how obvious the choice seems to everyone involved.
The First 72 Hours Most Parents Never Think About
When I meet with parents, most have thought about the big question: who would raise our kids if we weren't here? Very few have thought about the immediate question: what happens in the first 72 hours?
Who can pick your child up from school if you're suddenly hospitalized? Who can authorize medical treatment if your child is injured and you can't be reached? Who can step in immediately not after court paperwork, but right now?
This is one of the biggest planning gaps I see, and it's one we can solve before a crisis ever happens.
Here's the scenario I ask parents to imagine. Something happens to both of you on a Tuesday night. Your kids are with a babysitter. Emergency responders arrive. No one can quickly find a document naming who should take the children. The babysitter doesn't have legal authority. The neighbors don't have legal authority. Even grandparents living twenty minutes away may not have the legal authority to take custody on the spot.
So the system follows its procedures.
Your children could end up in temporary care with strangers not because anyone did anything wrong, but because no one left clear instructions about what should happen next. Meanwhile, your will is sitting in a drawer, a safe, or a lawyer's office. Even if it names guardians, those guardians still have to be formally appointed. That process takes time. It doesn't happen overnight.
This isn't some far-fetched worst-case scenario. It's a very real gap in most parents' planning.
A complete plan addresses two separate questions: Who raises your children long-term? And who has the authority to care for them immediately in the hours and days following an emergency? Most families focus on the first question and never answer the second.
That's where a Kids Protection Plan® makes all the difference.
When families have a Personal Family Lawyer® relationship, there is already a roadmap. There is already someone to call. Someone who knows the family, knows the plan, knows who was chosen, and can help make sure those wishes are carried out. Grandparents aren't left guessing. Guardians aren't scrambling for paperwork. The family isn't trying to navigate an impossible situation alone.
Bottom line: what happens in the first 72 hours can be just as important as what happens over the next 18 years. And it's the part of the plan most parents have never thought about.
The Real Reason This Stays on the To-Do List
When parents finally sit down with me to tackle this after putting it off for years, I usually ask what kept them from doing it sooner. The answer I hear most often? The decision feels too big.
What if we choose the wrong person? What if our relationship with them changes? What if the person who seems perfect today isn't the person we'd choose ten years from now? And what about the awkward conversation with the family member who doesn't get picked?
Those concerns are completely normal. But here's what I tell parents: naming a guardian isn't a once-and-for-all decision carved in stone. It's a decision based on the life, relationships, and circumstances you have today. As your children grow, your family evolves, and life changes, your plan can change too.
What matters most is having a plan in place now.
And yes, choosing between people you love can be uncomfortable. It may lead to difficult conversations. But avoiding the decision doesn't avoid the discomfort. It just shifts the burden to the people you love most and leaves the decision in the hands of a court if something happens to you first.
A judge won't know your family dynamics. They won't know why you would have chosen one person over another. They'll simply be left to sort through competing opinions after you're gone.
What I tell my clients is simple: you can always revisit and update a guardian designation. But if you never make the decision at all, you lose the chance to make it when it matters most.
Beyond "Who Would We Pick?"
When I help parents think through guardianship, most start with the same question: Who do we trust? And that's a great starting point. But it isn't the whole conversation.
The real question is this: Who would raise your children most like you would?
That's where we go deeper.
We talk about values. Does this person share your views on education, discipline, faith, family, and the things that matter most to you? Would your children feel at home in the life this person would create for them?
We talk about willingness. Have you actually asked them? Being the person you would choose and being willing to take on the responsibility are two very different things.
We talk about practical realities. Where do they live? Would your children have to move away from their school, friends, and community? Are they in a season of life where raising children is realistic?
We talk about age and health. Sometimes a grandparent feels like the obvious choice emotionally, but may not be the best fit for the next ten or fifteen years of your child's life.
We talk about siblings. If you have more than one child, can they keep the children together? Because preserving those relationships is often one of the most important factors in helping children navigate a loss.
And we always talk about backup plans. Life changes. Relationships change. Illness happens. The person who is the perfect choice today may not be available years from now. That's why naming backup guardians is just as important as naming your first choice.
If you're naming a couple, we talk through that, too. What happens if they divorce? What if one dies? What if their circumstances change dramatically? These are much easier questions to answer now than they are in a courtroom later.
And here's one misconception I clear up all the time: naming someone as a godparent does not make them a legal guardian. Neither does a conversation at a family barbecue, a verbal promise, or a shared understanding among relatives. The court only looks at legally executed documents.
There are rarely perfect answers. But the goal isn't to find the most responsible person in your family. It's to find the person whose values, lifestyle, and approach to raising children most closely matches your own.
Bottom line: the guardian question isn't simply, "Who do I trust?" It's, "Who would raise my children the way I would?" Sometimes those are the same person. Sometimes they aren't. That's why it's worth taking the time to ask the deeper questions.
The Value of Talking It Through
In my experience, naming a guardian is one of the most important decisions a parent will ever make. But it's also one of the most interconnected decisions in an estate plan, because it doesn't stand alone.
The person you want raising your children may not be the same person you want managing the money you leave behind for them. In fact, separating those roles is often the smartest choice. The person with the biggest heart isn't always the person with the strongest financial skills, and that's okay. A good plan allows you to choose the best person for each job.
It also forces you to think about something many parents overlook: even the best guardian will struggle if there isn't a financial plan supporting them. Choosing the right person is important. Making sure they have the resources, guidance, and support to care for your children is just as important.
That's why guardianship isn't a standalone decision. It connects to how money will be managed, who can step in immediately during an emergency, and how your children will be cared for both tomorrow and ten years from now.
When I work with parents, we don't just fill in a guardian's name and move on. We make sure the right people are chosen, the right resources are available, and the people you're counting on actually know what you've decided. Because a plan nobody knows about isn't much of a plan.
And the relationship doesn't end when the documents are signed. If something happens, your family knows who to call. I know your plan. I know the people you've chosen. I know what matters to you. And I can help your loved ones navigate a situation that no family should have to figure out alone.
There's one more thing I discuss with parents that surprises them almost every time: you can document not only who you want raising your children, but also who you do not want raising them. If there is someone you would never choose under any circumstance, we can put that in writing, too. In my view, that's one of the most protective things a parent can do, and it's something most families have never even been told is possible.
Bottom line: naming a guardian is important. But naming a guardian as part of a complete an Estate Plan, one that addresses the people, the money, the emergencies, and the real-world logistics is what truly protects your children.
What Every Parent Should Do Before Tonight
If you have children at home and haven't named guardians or if your guardian nomination exists only in a will and not as part of a comprehensive Kids Protection Plan®, I encourage you to make this a priority.
Not because something bad is about to happen. But because if it did, you would want the people caring for your children to be the ones you chose, not the ones a court chooses for you.
As a Personal Family Lawyer® Firm, we help families create an Estate Plan® that addresses who would raise your children, who can care for them immediately in an emergency, and how they will be financially supported if you're no longer here. We don't create one-size-fits-all documents and send you on your way. We take the time to understand your family, help you make thoughtful decisions, and build a plan designed to work when your loved ones need it most.
And the relationship doesn't end when the documents are signed. We stay connected so your plan can evolve as your family does, and so that if something happens, your loved ones have someone they can call who already knows your family and your wishes.
Schedule a complimentary 15-minute discovery call, and let's make sure your children are protected, starting today. https://pages.20westlegal.com/schedule/15-minute-intro-call
This article is a service of 20West Legal, a Personal Family Lawyer® Firm. We don’t just draft documents; we ensure you make informed and empowered decisions about life and death, for yourself and the people you love. That's why we offer an Estate Planning Session, during which you will get more financially organized than you’ve ever been before and make all the best choices for the people you love. You can begin by calling our office today to schedule an Estate Planning Session.
The content is sourced from Personal Family Lawyer® for use by Personal Family Lawyer firms, a source believed to be providing accurate information. This material was created for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as ERISA, tax, legal, or investment advice. If you are seeking legal advice specific to your needs, such advice services must be obtained on your own, separate from this educational material.
© 2026 20West Legal